You will find a shrine (M9,16) which starts the so called "Trail of Treats". In the first part of the fight, you can fight the Werewolf normally. #4. But as far as I can tell. An Eye for an Eye is a secondary quest in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and part of the Assassins' quests (the other two being A Deadly Plot and Redania's Most Wanted) needed for Reason of State. You can't free orphans and Anna. There are two ways to begin this quest. Version. Baron takes her to the mountains to search for healer. But if I’m to choose between one evil and another, then I prefer not to choose at all. Toussaint. (3) Kill the Leshen, get the trophy. There are 2 outcomes to the Baron's story line: Destroy the tree spirit = Anna lives (she doesn't transform), thus the baron lives. . Particularly for the children. That's not how it works. The Baron leaves, taking her to a healer. And while it feels terrible knowing the Crones kill those children when you kill the spirit, Geralt and Ciri eventually kill all the Crones anyway, freeing the land of their influence, and ending all the child sacrifice (at least, to the Crones specifically). Even though the village was destroyed, which was more lifes than the orphans; however, it saves many future generations of innocent children from becoming witch meal. Once it starts you will have already free'd the spirit but the game will let you keep your end of the bargain and save Anna. Now, three hours and many quests later, the baron hanged himself. Accidentally got the "best" ending for the Bloody Baron. . Ciri ’s Story: Fleeing the Bog is another straight forward quest. The easiest way to jump back into The Witcher 3 is to load an old save file from wherever you last left off. To protect Anna, the kids, and whoever else it makes sense to kill the spirit that has shown itself already to be more than willingly kill humans so as to not ire the crones. The Witcher 3 game plays in late spring and early summer of 1272. Repeat one more time to kill the tree spirit. Buy the Witcher 3: Wild Hunt / Support CD Projekt Red: on a few ending basing on what political party you chose to put in power. But yeah, sadly, you had to choose in this case. You are never given an opportunity to kill the Crones at any time during this quest line, so killing them is not possible either. You kill the spirit, the orphans are all doomed, Anna goes mad, Bloody Baron hopes to cure her and lives. By Xyoz Quasar. Geralt level: 34 Installation: Unzip the folder and copy the SAV- file to your Witcher 3 gamesaves folder. The quest for this particular achievement is called 'Heart of the Woods' and is located in Fayrlund, Skellige. The book says that the tree spirit was so mad and evil that even the crones feared her and her actions after release of mercilessly killing an entire village seem in line with that. He and some men have gathered there to prepare rescue mission into the bog to save the baron’s wife. Free the spirit from the tree (save the kids) and lose and ally later or kill the tree (lose the kids) and gain one. She won't be eager to help you, but the kids will. Knowing beforehand the crowns are evil how is agreeing to kill the tree sprit a good thing and saving him only makes the outcome worse and it becomes a horse. The Ghost in the Tree is a creature in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. If you read some books in the game. In my opinion, the lives of several children are worth more than the lives of Anna and the Baron. For The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "What's the best outcome if you free the tree spirit or kill it? (SPOILERS)" - Page 4. The Witcher 3 The Wild Hunt - How to get the best ending - secret ending (THIRD OPTION). เข้าสู่ระบบ ร้านค้าFree the Spirit, save the children, and save Anna. You won't achieve an happy ending by killing the tree spirit, but it's still way happier then freeing it. If you chose to kill the Ghost in the Tree, the town of Downwarren will survive. there are 3 outcomes to this quest. Asuryan Jan 16, 2017 @ 2:41am. - Go back to the spirit and free it. More than anything I did not trust them, and did not want to do anything to potentially strengthen their hold over the swamp. Ps there is actually away to kill the tree spirit and save the wife and the baron doesnt kill himself. Letho enlisted the help of Iorveth and the Scoia'tael to aid him in his plan to kill the kings of the Northern Kingdoms; to back his claim, the Viper showed. READ THE RULES BEFORE POSTING. Installation. For The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, the English voice actors were directed by Kate Saxon, with additional directing by Mark Healy and Damien Goodwin. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. you free the spirit before you get the quest from the crones the. It's choosing between Chaotic Neutral (Tree Spirit) and Lawful Evil (Crones). Quests like 'The Whispering Hillock' show that the world contained within is actually pretty grim. 1. -Went to the Whispering Hillock met the spirit told it I had to think on it. MMF_Legacy 7 years ago #19. The Old Crones are evil. Asuryan Jan 16, 2017 @ 2:41am. GGuts • 4 yr. XtremeDeath 8 years ago #5. She's the mother of the Crones. Free the tree spirit, so she can save the orphan, but at the same time she destroys a nearby village. For werewolves, you. All you poop-for-brains. If instead of slaying the beast, Geralt frees the spirit beneath the tree,. Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - Meeting the Crones after Releasing the Spirit in the Tree Buy the Witcher 3: Wild Hunt / Support CD Projekt Red: the spirit went crazy and started killing people so the crones, who are her (it's supposed to be a woman) daughters, imprisoned her there. 2. Knowing beforehand the crowns are evil how is agreeing to kill the tree sprit a good thing and. Saving her means leaving them where they are, most likely to have been eaten by the time Geralt returns with the Baron for Anna. I could be wrong. ago. Therefore, going off of what you stated, I would venture that letting the spirit free was the lesser evil. I had heard somewhere that this was possible if you freed the tree spirit before starting the Crone's quest, but I didn't do that. Killing the spirit results to the children being eaten by the crones. That's a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥. So I'm playing the witcher 3 and I got to a part where these 3 witches want me to kill this tree spirit and I didn't no what to do so I looked up the outcome of both and I no which one I want to pick now but since I cheated. First playthrough, just randomly running around Velen. Installation: 1. 8k more. You'll have to decide what to. Once you've freed it, go back to the bog and resume following Johnny and continue the quest as normal. But what I am saying, is any ending that frees the tree spirit, goes against what a witcher was created to do. Freeing the tree spirit will anger the crones. Witcher 3 Hearts of Stone - Freeing the Tree Spirit & Keeping the Baron and His Wife Anna Alive Witcher 3 Blood and Wine Complete Playlist: Especially compared to wiki's for other games, like Dragon Age which is extremely thorough with every single dialogue option and consequences of them etc. I guess if you haven't played The Witcher 3 this is spoiler so continue at your own risk. Baron takes her to the mountains to search for healer. She ends up unconscious in the bog where the three. Use Igni to cause burning so you can dash in to deliver some heavy blows with your sword. This will draw the creature out, allowing Geralt to kill it. But the children won't be saved. Mod manager download. " You can also activate this quest by running into the group of people on the road just southwest of Fayrlund, which is where the quest takes. You'll have to make what feel like bad decisions at certain points that might. The Polish voice actors were directed by Konrad Tomaszkiewicz and Michal Konarski. If you do this BEFORE starting “Ladies of the Wood”, the tree will not have made the promise of saving the children. But: the baron and his wife dies and the…Use your Witcher Senses on Hilde, the woman outside the house with crows flying overhead in the west of the village. Lynch Mob is a secondary quest in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. When you arrive, take a look around town. That's what ultimately made me decide to go back and release the tree spirit. Kill a few of. You encounter the Whispering Hillock after the Crones mention it. The Baron deserves to die. Killing the tree spirit will immediately make the children go missing from the game world. For Keira Metz, her fate is in the players' hands. But I. I literally had no clue what it was and even after finishing the Crones stuff I still didn't know, except later when I returned to the guy who. Magic acorn from the oak tree grown on the peak of Bald Mountain in Velen. If you release the tree spirit prior to the part where the crones tell you to kill it then both the Children and the baron and his wife live. -Got it's stuff-Choose to do the ritual. LITCH May 31, 2015 @ 2:40am. My path to missing the least content in a single playthrough. Follow the cave path. Buy the Witcher 3: Wild Hunt / Support CD Projekt Red: 3 Wild Hunt: Release the spirit trapped in the tree and rescue Anna from crookback Bog without her turning into a waterhag . The villagers believe the book She Who Knows which implies she was a more powerful being capable of resolving the people's issues for sacrifices of grain, animals and men. Killing the Crones and freeing the spirit will save the children (and Anna). Which gives us 3 endings indeed : go to the crones, kill spirit, children are eaten, Anna is crazy, village is ok. When the Crones talk about the Tree Spirit, tell them you freed it. CryptoKnowing beforehand the crowns are evil how is agreeing to kill the tree sprit a good thing and saving him only makes the outcome worse and it becomes a horse. Kill tree spirit and the crones eat the kids. If the spirit is killed the people of Downwarren will not be harmed later however, it is hinted that the Witches of Crookback bog kill and eat. Weird how now it seems like some long forgotten lost. I don't understand why, when you have to make the decision of killing the Tree-Spirit or saving its life, some people (the majority from what I've heard) kill the spirit. Cantabiley Jul 5, 2015 @ 10:15am. There is no black or white outcome, you should decide between the lesser evil, following the phylosophy of the Witcher books. My backup saved game. It wants to slaughter an entire village and whisk away the children. Kill the werewolf. 1,234 ratings. Letho enlisted the help of Iorveth and the Scoia'tael to aid him in his plan to kill the kings of the Northern Kingdoms; to back his claim, the Viper showed. An other story is more positiv for the tree witches. Tree Spirit/Crones -Spoilers-The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt PlayStation 4 . I think I have saved everyone. One of my most favourite quotes of the books. Indeed, the Lady becomes mad threatening any Velen. I killed the spirit inside the tree and the Baron ends up taking his wife, Anna, away to a far away healer. Best outcome is to let the tree live. Knowing beforehand the crowns are evil how is agreeing to kill the tree sprit a good thing and saving him only makes the outcome worse and it becomes a horse. kill the tree, so everyone lives. It also claims she created the crones herself as daughters, but then started to become mad, so the daughters killed her and trapped her spirit in the tree. Should I free or kill the tree spirit Witcher 3? Killing the Tree Spirit- If you choose to kill the tree, the tree will put up a shield and summon three endreagas that attack. It has a lot of health and will kill you in 1-2 hits. Quests like 'The Whispering Hillock' show that the world contained within is actually pretty grim. Has anyone encountered this bug before if so, how do i fix it. The Ghost in the Tree was the spirit of a druid, located beneath the Ancient Oak in a forested area south of Downwarren. The recommended level is 22. #4. Woodland Spirit is a very old and very powerful leshen worshiped by the elders of the village of Fayrlund but is disliked by the younger inhabits of the village led by Sven. Witcher 3 Hearts of Stone - Freeing the Tree Spirit & Keeping the Baron and His Wife Anna Alive Witcher 3 Blood and Wine Complete Playlist: was doing another play-through of The Witcher 3, and got to that fateful choice between sparing or killing The Ghost in the Tree. Whereas the old crones represent cruel order, and a ritualistic cycle of controlled suffering. That's just a theory though. Thus I decided to go along with freeing the spirit and thus freeing the children. Import a Save File. So either you choose the kids, or the baron's wife. Save File Location ( C:Users"User"DocumentsThe Witcher 3gamesaves) All the good decisions are selected in every quest. The quest can also be done before the eve…You can also save the Baron and his wife in the quest "Return to Crookback Bog" if you make the correct choices. Go to the south of the location, to the swamps. Kill them. Thus I decided to go along with freeing the spirit and thus freeing the children. Killing the spirit results to the children being eaten by the crones. Belépés Áruház Főoldal Felfedezési várólista Kívánságlista Pontbolt Hírek StatisztikákIf you havent completed the quest yet, finish it first and do what you think is the right choice. This notice board is at the Kaer Trolde Harbor. XtremeDeath 8 years ago #5. Some of these missions may be more important than you think, and the choices you. As Geralt explains to Cerys, there are two ways to get rid of the Hym: The Witcher Way - Spend a night with the affected individual in the Hym's lair. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is a massive open-world adventure with hundreds of quests and activities to take part in. No, you can't. (protect humans from evil monsters) By freeing the tree spirit before you get the quest from the crones, it doesn't trigger the crones freed spirit response & you get the killed the tree spirit dialogue & outcomes. She (Black Stallion) represents the wild chaos of nature. updated Dec 6, 2022. The wife the baron will live and also the village will be safe. You’ll need to go. –Harald of Fayrlund Some monsters are so powerful local. 1. Both the Crones and the Tree Spirit are their own. Jan 8, 2017. Now, three hours and many quests later, the baron hanged himself. During this quest, you'll get two options to. Look up to see dozens of ravens on the branches of the oak trees. Spirit destroys a whole village. As you may have guessed from their conversations with you, you have not seen the last of the crones. Knowing beforehand the crowns are evil how is agreeing to kill the tree sprit a good thing and saving him only makes the outcome worse and it becomes a horse. ”. kill tree spirit or no? if i free the evil tre the children is free if i killed what happend than>? Anmelden Shop Startseite Entdeckungsliste Wunschliste Punkteshop Neuigkeiten StatistikenThe start point is at Reardon Manor, which is just north of Downwarren in Velen. Just down one flight of stairs and the trail will stop at a single floorboard. Killing the spirit results to the children being eaten by the crones. Ladies of teh wood: free the spirit under the tree The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt PlayStation 4 . If you wanted a master tip of sorts to beefing out Geralt to his fullest potential, then this is it. Tell it you won't help and you fight a swarm of Endrega. Trick It - Someone can pretend to do something horrible, which will convince the Hym to infect them instead. Grab it and swim back to the surface. A treasure hunt of sorts. Head to the village of Downwarren to meet the baron. "Woodland Spirit" Complete the contract on the Woodland Spirit. Simply save your game, use a respec potion and saturate a chosen skill tree with points. Spirit destroys a whole village. If you havent completed the quest yet, finish it first and do what you think is the right choice. 1. If you've skill in undoing such charms, or even if you have heard of a worthy cunning man or pellar who has such a gift, seek me out in my house. To start the In the Eternal Fire’s Shadow quest you have to go to the Devil’s Pit in Velen. One of the most compelling characters throughout The Witcher 3 's lengthy story is Phillip Strenger, better known as The Bloody Baron. Hopefully, our old friend Triss will have seen her. A lot of mystery surrounds the spirit but one thing appears to be certain: she wasn't human and the Crones killed her (or rather, destroyed her body) then captured her spirit. Free the tree spirit and the kids live but tree spirit kills everyone in village. Yeah I set the tree free before meeting the orphans and Anna and got the good ending for Anna and the. Choices matter, but that doesn't mean you'll necessarily have any good choices. Baron takes her to the mountains to search for healer. Accedi Negozio Pagina principale Elenco scoperte Lista dei desideri Negozio dei punti Notizie Statistiche100% complete save for Witcher 3: Wild Hunt + All DLC's incl. THIS SAVE INCLUDES: - Completed Undiscovered Locations (including Kaer Morhen and Toussaint) - Completed Gwent Deck (including Skellige deck, does not include the ones you win from Gwent quests) - Completed Treasure Hunts (including Grandmaster Gear) - Completed Witcher Contracts. However, the Witcher wiki is mentioning. What you do or don't do will affect late game. It only mentions the orphans and how it can save them. darkflemish Feb 3 @ 3:58am. After. Baron's wife doesn't end up dead, but a bit crazy. Baron takes her to the mountains to search for healer. The part that changes however is the Children were not apart of your Bargain with the Tree i. Should I kill the tree spirit? Side Quest. Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - Tricking the Ghost in the Tree on the Whispering Hillock. but the Baron's wife/family is safe, and the nearby. Basically says the Tree Spirit is the Crones mother that went mad so the Crones had to kill it so the book is saying it's evil but since the book is biased/untrue the Tree Spirit is. To kill the Evil Tree Spirit or Not to kill the Evil Tree Spirit? That is the question. Return to Crookback Bog can be obtained by agreeing to help the Bloody Baron. Whereas the old crones represent cruel order, and a ritualistic cycle of controlled suffering. 2. When he tells you to follow him back to the orphanage, leave instead and go do the Whispering Hillock quest with the Tree Spirit. What happens if you help the tree spirit Witcher 3? Ride the horse back to the tree spirit to free the spirit. 21 or higher. Agree to help and then betray it when you start the ritual. Horror. ”. Especially with the children involved. The story in The Witcher 3 is very complex and dependent on your in-game choic. I can't ♥♥♥♥ing decide whether to save the damn children and let Velen get ♥♥♥♥ed by the Baron's guys becoming bandits, or let the children die but allow better outcome for Velen. Enter the hut and activate witcher senses. The Crones, also called the Ladies of the Wood, are three witches who live in a cabin in the swamps of Velen. I know I probably shouldn't care but came across a thread somewhere that said it's possible to save the Baron, his wife Ana and the orphan children while the spirit in the tree ends up killing the village. . e. But given the tree spirit also could actually be the mother of the crones and was supposedly imprisoned for being. You'll find me chopping wood near Fox Hollow – my name's Jacob, and chopping wood's what I do. 2: Talk to Sven. What's the best outcome if you free the tree spirit or kill it? (SPOILERS) maiden1993 8 years ago #21 Kill the tree. Dismantle your Shells to receive Pearls. Freed the tree spirit, saved the orphans and after that liberated Anna I think. The Witcher 3 - 100% Achievement Guide. There's been a lot of debate about the "right" choice to make here, but I think I've found some information that may shed some light on the true identity of the spirit, and make this choice a bit easier. Sadly there's no everybody lives ending here. There's a chance the spirit is much worse than the crones too. 8k more. Help the tree spirit (free the children, and in doing so, pissing off the Crones) = Anna dies after released from the curse, and later Baron dies too. Imperial Audience is a main quest in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and the final quest in the game's prologue. Explore as much as. Only had one baron outcome and he died but have heard depending on your choices he can live but don't know exact choices and I think there are more than "two" scenarios. CryptoI saved before I decided. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. go to the crones, free spirit, children are saved, Anna dies, village is destroyed. Spirit destroys a whole village. Killing the spirit results to the children being eaten by the crones. . READ THE RULES BEFORE POSTING. This affects the course of events and the length of the entire quest. Log in to add games to your lists. Killing the tree spirit will immediately make the children go missing from the game world. Killing or Saving The Tree Spirit. Therefore, going off of what you stated, I would venture that letting the spirit free was the lesser evil. greigy Feb 3 @ 4:00am. If you freed the tree spirit in “The. Or ignore the "Reason of State" quest and let it fail. The trophy is missable because you can finish the quest in two different kinds, and to unlock the trophy you MUST kill the monster. Yes, you should kill the Tree Spirit in the Whispering Hillock quest in Witcher 3 if you want the village of Downwarren to stay safe. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 100% complete save for Witcher 3: Wild Hunt + All DLC's incl. I’m not a pious hermit. You are never given an opportunity to kill the Crones at any time during this quest line, so killing them is not possible either. ”. Yes, the Baron's men start murdering and pillaging regardless of whether you kill the tree spirit or not. Tree does not save the Kids but is freed, which does not enrage the Crones, Anna remains Human and the "Good" story goes on As to the morality of the choice, it all boils down to this being a story about shades of Grey, not Black or White. Baron's wife doesn't end up dead, but a bit crazy. SPOILERS HO! I went with freeing the spirit. Preparing For Battle. Just uploading this for someone that. So that kinda is the worst since everyone dies. Standard: C: > User > Username > Documents > The Witcher 3 > gamesaves NOTE: This savegame is compatible with game version 1. Pick up the Woodland Beast Contract at either the Border Post or Oxenfurt notice boards. Walkthrough. 5: Continue following the footprints to the top of the hill. No matter what you do, it's gonna end in tears for someone. Thus I decided to go along with freeing the spirit and thus freeing the children. His closest associates were Auckes and Serrit, also kingslayers and fellow witchers from the School of the Viper. Regarding the Whispering Hillock - I think it's one of the most difficult decisions in the game. Im currently at the Tree spirit mission where i am supposed to choose to kill or save the tree spirit, I chose to kill it but the spirit stays at 60% health and wont die. FC: 2294-6661-8137. Wine Wars: Belgaard is a secondary quest in the Blood and Wine expansion. Always activate the Quen Sign to protect yourself from damage. Killing the tree spirit will immediately make the children go missing from the game world. Answer 1: “I’ll help you” (Release the spirit) If you choose to help the Ghost in the Tree, you’ll need three things to complete a ritual: raven feathers, the spirit’s. Contract: Woodland Beast is a contract quest in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Total DLs. the ultimate witcher 3 debate:. - Story Mode. By following this guide you will avoid missing. In this quest, Geralt is asked by Baron Phillip Strenger to help him find his missing wife (Anna) and daughter (Tamara) in exchange for information regarding Ciri's whereabouts. A subreddit for discussions, news, memes, media, and other topics pertaining to the third installment in the Witcher games franchise. Ladies of the Wood Walkthrough. 1 Answer. We've offended him, Sven. Geralt of Rivia. com You can also save the Baron and his wife in the quest "Return to Crookback Bog" if you make the correct choices. The children are freed as a side benefit. The Crones will be satisfied, which is good for Gran and the village of Downwarren, but not for the children. He promises his daughter that he wont give up on her and they have somewhat of a bittersweet reunion and farewell. In the beginning of The Witcher 3, Geralt and his mentor Vesemir are trying to track down the Sorceress Yennefer's whereabouts. Next: The Witcher 3: Complete Guide And Walkthrough. The Whispering Hillock is a main quest in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt though, if found before progressing far enough in the main, will instead appear as a secondary quest. Yeah I also heard that. You get the Secondary Quest In the Heart of the Woods in Fayrlund, Skellige. The trader at Crow's Perch stocks this book, which may be particularly helpful for Ivar. Besides, Anna dies either way, only when killing the tree, she dies psychologically. The spirit in the tree only offers to save the children if you free it while doing the Baron's questline. The Whispering Hillock - Killed the tree spirit IMPORTANT: Trish and Yennefer are important characters in the game, and their romance options are important choices. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. After some time the Werewolf will. เข้าสู่ระบบ ร้านค้าWitcher 3: The Whispering Hillock - the crones ask us to assist the elder of Downwarren by destroying the heart of a giant tree, inhabited by a druid ghost. The altar is located on a hill near a large tree. If you chose to kill the Ghost in the Tree. ) This also robs the Crones of their meal, which is nice. Iniciar sessão Loja Início Fila de Descoberta Lista de Desejos Loja de Pontos Notícias EstatísticasA subreddit for discussions, news, memes, media, and other topics pertaining to the third installment in the Witcher games franchise. But i do know for a fact you can save the tree spirit and save the wife and the baron doesnt kill himself. A Towerful of Mice Walkthrough. The Baron Dies. Now, three hours and many quests later, the baron hanged himself. Really love his character arc. #1. Legend suggests the three are sisters and the daughters of the original "Lady of the Wood", also known as "She-Who-Knows". What you do or don't do will affect late game. Ciri is on the run from the Wild Hunt and she is badly wounded. Now I dont want to do it all over again, so I hope. Follow the path to the Gran hut (M9,17). . The tree spirit is not "evil. More Fandoms. The Witcher 3: The Wild Hunt is a fascinating RPG that presents the player with a number of interesting and difficult choices to make throughout the course of the story. Free the spirit = The spirit will save the children, but Hannah and the baron will die, and the village will be devastated by the spirit. Tree Spirit/Crones -Spoilers-The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt PlayStation 4 . If you choose to attack the monster, you’ll draw your sword and fight. Inloggen Winkel Startpagina Ontdekkingswachtrij Verlanglijst Puntenwinkel Nieuws StatistiekenKnowing beforehand the crowns are evil how is agreeing to kill the tree sprit a good thing and saving him only makes the outcome worse and it becomes a horse. Phillip Strenger, commonly known as the Bloody Baron, was a self-proclaimed baron located in Velen. But the tree spirit will be freed and Gran WON’T be in danger. You will meet them at some point of the main quest, when you have to talk to Dandelion's maitresses. Knowing beforehand the crowns are evil how is agreeing to kill the tree sprit a good thing and saving him only makes the outcome worse and it becomes a horse. However. You will know the tree spirit you just release is the mother or the creator of the crones. ”. When you. That's not how it works. Nithing I'm asking for help from any who can give it. The spirit destroys Downwarren, the Crones get the kids, and Anna lives. Find Witcher Gear, Treasure, Gwent Players, Signposts & everything else! Use the progress tracker to get 100%! The Witcher 3 Maps. Only way to save them is killing it. When he tells you to follow him back to the orphanage, leave instead and go do the Whispering Hillock quest with the Tree Spirit. The altar is to the left of the oak tree. The big moral dilemma is to make you feel back about not saving the orphans. you free the spirit it kills all the villagers in downwarren. Return to Crookback Bog is a Secondary Quest in The Witcher 3 Wild Hunt. He then describes what the acorns are used for, explaining that. Geralt meets this less than savory character when the witcher is directed to Crow's Perch in Velen during his initial search. Drowned Velen in blood to be exact. The orphans get eaten if you kill the tree spirit Anyway, TC there are negative consequences to freeing the spirit. The important thing is that you accept Sven's offer who wants you to kill the Woodland Spirit (the younger man) and not the offer from Harald (the elderly man). The Spirit does not offer to save them. I agree, it just combines the outcomes of each ending together, except the orphans don't show up later in the game. The shrine that starts the path to the witches. It’d be like releasing Morgoth because you distrust Sauron. Some choices will be minor. -Went to the Whispering Hillock met the spirit told it I had to think on it. In the walkthrough, we mention a number of. Either the orphans die or the Baron's wife does. Agree to help and then betray it when you start the ritual. If the ghost is killed, then Anna 'the Barons wife) will survive, but is clearly suffering - Baron will take her to folk healer in the. Regarding the Whispering Hillock - I think it's one of the most difficult decisions in the game.